SPS Seminar: Daniel Goldstein (University of Oslo) - "Elites as Democratic Gatekeepers: Theory and Evidence from Norway"

Job Market
Speakers
Daniel Goldstein, University of Oslo
5:00pm - 6:15pm
Room AS01 (Roentgen -2)

Numerous studies have examined voters’ support for democracy and reactions to democratic
violations by elites. Yet, we know less about the democratic preferences of political
elites. This gap matters because elites may act as “democratic gatekeepers” by
blocking autocratic colleagues from power. We develop a theory of elite gatekeeping
and test it using pre-registered survey experiments on a sample of approximately 2,000
national, regional, and local representatives and party officials in Norway. Using multiple
experimental designs, we measure internal gatekeeping – the willingness to punish
anti-democratic colleagues within one’s own party – and external gatekeeping – the
willingness to block a governing coalition with anti-democratic parties. Elites engage in
both, but neither is absolute: the penalty for anti-democratic behavior is no larger than
for ordinary misconduct, and roughly 70% would accept an anti-democratic coalition
partner when it secures a governing majority. Democracy’s gatekeepers may be less
steadfast than they appear.